Oregon's attorney general, Dan Rayfield, sued OpenAI on Tuesday, Nov. 17, in the circuit court for Multnomah County, Oregon. His office says the company misled the public about how safe ChatGPT is for children, sold it with serious safety problems it did not disclose, and used unfair tactics to market it to children and teens. Those claims rest on the Unlawful Trade Practices Act, Oregon's consumer protection law. The suit also says OpenAI was negligent and profited unfairly at Oregonians' expense. It says ChatGPT is a public nuisance, which under Oregon law means unreasonable interference with a right shared by the whole public, in this case Oregonians' right to peace, safety and happiness, which the state says ChatGPT threatens for children. The suit names six OpenAI companies, but not the company's chief executive.
The complaint, the court filing that starts the case, puts a floor on the harm and costs the state alleges. In its negligence and public nuisance claims, it says Oregon has been harmed and will keep paying to repair the harm to its residents, in an amount to be proved at trial but not less than $2.035 billion. The state also asks for civil penalties, fines paid to the state, for each willful violation of the consumer law. It asks for money to make up for harm to Oregon residents, and for OpenAI to give up profits the state says it made unfairly.
It wants court orders that bar OpenAI from misstating how safe and suitable ChatGPT and its teen version are for children. The orders would also require age checks and protections against harmful content that work, and parental controls and safety alerts that do what OpenAI says they do. The state wants a jury to decide the case.
Much of the case is about ChatGPT for Teens, a version of the chatbot OpenAI launched on Aug. 18. OpenAI says the teen version has stronger built-in safety protections and more controls for parents, and that people its system estimates are under 18, or who say they are 13 to 17, are placed in it automatically. Oregon says linking a parent's account is optional, so a teen can use ChatGPT with no parent connected. Citing tests by Common Sense Media, a children's advocacy group that once partnered with OpenAI, the complaint says the teen version sent parents with linked accounts no alert when testers raised suicide, self-harm, psychosis or disordered eating, until weeks of such talk had passed. It says that in a quarter of more than 200 prompts that called for a crisis response, the teen version offered no hotline, professional or other place to turn. The group said ChatGPT should be for adults only until OpenAI fixes its safety alerts and proves the fix with independent testing.
An OpenAI spokesperson, Drew Pusateri, said the company has built protections for teenagers that many other AI products lack and keeps working with experts to strengthen them, according to a news report. He said OpenAI is committed to working with states on "pragmatic AI policies that apply to the entire AI industry and not just one company."
"OpenAI knows that ChatGPT is harming children, and has failed to meaningfully fix their dangerous platform," Rayfield said. He told a reporter that no single incident in Oregon led to the suit, which he said grew out of cases across the country. The case is part of what his office calls its Keeping Kids Safe Initiative, launched the same day. It also takes in earlier work: a $125 million settlement with Meta that limits how long children can use Instagram and Facebook each day, and an investigation into Discord that began earlier this year. His office says more actions against companies that harm children will follow in the coming weeks and months.
Oregon is not the first state to sue. Iowa said on Oct. 14 that it and seven other states had each sued OpenAI in their own courts, and Texas sued OpenAI and its chief executive, Sam Altman, on Oct. 23. These are accusations, and none of them has been proved in court. Oregon's complaint does not say how the state arrived at the $2.035 billion figure or how many Oregon children it believes were harmed. Rayfield said his office based it on an estimate of how many Oregon children use ChatGPT and the penalties involved, according to a news report.